Sunday, July 15, 2012
Learning and Happiness
Outdoor adventures, certainly.
Reading books.
Teaching classes.
Playing board games.
Talking to interesting people.
What do these things have in common?
Learning.
So, let's take outdoor adventures. I really enjoy them all, but they really sing to my soul when I go new places or learn new skills.
Or let's take board games. One wouldn't think they're a learning experience (and sometimes they're not), but, again, they're at their best when I discover new strategies or ways of seeing them.
Or, crossword puzzles, which I've decided I love. I learn new words, new associations, new ways of thinking.
I hope to dedicate my weekly blog to stuff I've learned. Maybe a daily Facebook post on what I've learned too.
Sunday, July 8, 2012
Institutions Are Destiny
The book is written for a general audience, and if you're feeling smart and ambitious, it is well worth reading. It aims to be the "Guns, Germs, and Steel" of the social sciences. The thesis in "Guns, Germs, and Steel" is that Geography/Climate is Destiny. Civilization arose and thrived where geography and climate endowed people with the most nutritious and easily cultivatable food. Those locations created dynamic human societies that gave rise to complex socio-political institutions, sophisticated languages, inventions, and so forth.
"Why Nations Fail" addresses not the rise of civilization but rather the success and failure of modern nation-states. Why, for example, has the United States succeeded so much better than Mexico? The answer: Institutions are Destiny. Where inclusive, democratic-style political institutions are put in place early on, they produce economic progress and all good things, like rapid technological advances. American colonists got it right; Spanish colonists did not. All else flows from this. (Though, if forced to pick a single moment on which the fulcrum of history swings, "Why Nations Fail" would choose the 1688 Glorious Revolution in England rather than the founding of America.)
Most people I know already believe that the founding of the United States and its associated institutions (Declaration of Independence and the Constitution) are in fact responsible for the great things that have happened in this country. But this book only occasionally looks at the United States. It gazes more frequently at examples of poor political institutions, probably because there are many more examples to choose from. In recounting all the political institutions you've never heard of (from long-gone African kingdoms to colonial patterns in Central America), the book takes readers on a fascinating journey.
The book excels at drawing connections between those institutions and good economic outcomes, like growth and innovation. I've always believed that institutions are destiny. This book illustrates the ways in which institutions shape social and economic activity by using broad patterns and, at times, careful historical process-tracing. The case of the Southern United States is a fascinating example. The South failed to get its institutions right after the Civil War and thus descended into another 100-plus years of less robust growth and economic progress than the rest of the United States.
What does the book not do? It does not explain how these institutions arise, though at times it wants to. It also does not give enough credit to the importance of values and ideas. It might also underplay the importance of human capital (i.e., education). Wordiness is a problem; many chapters repeat main points far too frequently. But, all in all, a fabulous book and amazing achievement.
Sunday, July 1, 2012
Adventure Books
Then Ellen read a youth book in her young adult literature class about Shackleton's South Pole adventure that was tremendous, "Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World." I loved it. So, when I started thinking about fun summer reading, I looked around for the best.
I found this sweet list by National Geographic: http://www.nationalgeographic.com/adventure/0404/adventure_books.html
The 100 best adventure books of all time. Into Thin Air is in the top 10, but was checked out from my public library. So I went with "Annapurna," the story of the first summit of a 26,000-foot peak, in 1950. It's pretty amazing. I also read "No Way Down," which is not on the list but is about a deadly day on K2, where 11 of 24 climbers died. It is excellent. So, I've found a new genre I love. I gave the K2 book to Nathan, who is also really enjoying it.
"Annapurna" deserves its place on the list of classics because the writing is really beautiful (translated from French). He is an adventurer with a gift for describing the scenery and the happenings around him. It also deserves a place because the book offers perhaps the best statements I've seen on what motivates folks like him. He lost all fingers and toes to frostbite and the journey down the mountain was agony. Yet he explains so well what drove him and he feels the cost was worth it. This isn't eloquent, but it boils down to: "It's just who I am and I have to be true to myself." From these books, I learn that great explorers have some serious egos and aren't the friendliest folks around or the easiest to get along with.
Monday, June 18, 2012
The death of the university?
We need only wait, say they, to see if online content resembles an Amazon model or an Ebay model.
It's amazing that supposedly smart people get away with such balderdash.
First, a bit of history. When I was interviewing for jobs 15 years ago, I sat on an airplane next to a guy who was recording the world's best professors at top universities. He wondered why I was even bothering with a career that would soon die because everyone would pay to watch videos of the best teachers. Hmmmm. Well, I'm still here, and I see "great lecture" courses offered for extremely steep discounts.
So, now the trend is toward offering videos or "courses" online for free for low charge. Perhaps this should be labeled the "Wikipedia" model. I've looked at a couple of these, including MIT's "every course is online" project and the "Kahn Academy." I'm deeply unimpressed. The video lectures seem well-done, but there are two fundamental problems.
1-Learning requires interactivity. Watching a video is very different from interacting with a faculty member and fellow students in class. These videos perpetuate the worst possible teaching techniques: lecturing to a disconnected audience. That's not what higher education is, and online videos are free or cheap because that's their basic value: close to zero. The really valuable resource is the time of smart people, both students and faculty, and that's a very limited resource.
2-The proliferation of videos will lead to the same problem Wikipedia faces: low information about the quality of an article. When I read a Wikipedia article, I learn stuff. But I am always amazed at the level of contestation going on about virtually every article. Monitors regularly point to unsubstantiated or disputed "facts" or interpretations and most discussions about the problems seem to bog down in interminable debates. One can never be sure about the quality of the information. And, for topics, I know something about, Wikipedia barely grazes the surface, so the safe assumption is that the information is fairly low quality. Something can be reasonably fair and correct, by the way, and still be low-quality.
So, there you go: If you want lectures with low levels of interaction and uncertain quality, nearly free online education looks very promising indeed. For something of quality, I expect folks will need to pay.
Sunday, April 22, 2012
NYC and Other Great Cities
Sunday, April 15, 2012
On Ghastly Gashes
Monday, April 2, 2012
Violence in Film
Sunday, March 18, 2012
TV
Sunday, March 11, 2012
Evaluating Teachers
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Winter Adventures: Silver Lake
Sunday, February 12, 2012
Adele and Lin
I'm trying to think of the last time I loved a female vocalist. Maybe never. I suppose maybe Diana Krall and, back when I was in grad school when I first discovered Ella Fitzgerald (whom I still adore). There have been a few others. I certainly like a lot of them and can name a bunch, from pop to jazz. But love? Where I read about them on Wikipedia and can recount what I learn? And track down Youtube videos, and watch one of those videos ("Someone Like You," performed in Adele's home) more than once? Nah. I don't do ANYTHING more than once. Not even stuff I love, like hiking or canyoneering or mountain biking. I'm always looking for a new route. But I've watched "Someone Like You" three times. That's true love.
And Jeremy Lin. He may not endure; I'm not sure. I'm pretty sure Adele will last, both in popular culture and as someone I admire. Lin may be a flash in the pan. I'm not sure. He doesn't look like a passing fad, but it's tough to know. And the last NBA player I loved? Um, probably never. I don't think I would like to meet most of them. Gordon Hayward seems like a decent fellow. Among former Jazz players, Thurl Bailey, John Stockton and Jeff Hornacek would be fine dinner companions, I'm sure. Malone, on the other hand, doesn't seem my type. Chris Paul and Blake Griffin are certainly admirable and fun to watch, as are many others. But making me excited to watch or to feel happy for them? Nah. Only Lin.
So what do Adele and Lin have in common? Both seem immensely talented folks who have been true to self while battling some adversity. Adele was the daughter of a teenage mother who got noticed when songs for a class project were posted to myspace. Lin got turned down at the college level for scholarships and so went to Harvard, hardly the best way to launch a basketball career. They are the quiet, determined underdogs who succeed without ridiculous antics and without playing to stereotypes of female sexuality or male machismo. That's a sure way to my heart.
Sunday, February 5, 2012
Nonfiction for Youth
The books Ellen is reading are different. They are like the best nonfiction for adults in the sense that the high-quality writing is part of the accomplishment. But they actually exceed adult nonfiction in bringing their subject alive because they employ graphical material in such a superior way. By graphical material I mean photos, illustrations, maps, and layout design. The two most amazing I've seen so far are "Black Potatoes" about the Irish potato famine and "Shipwreck at the Bottom of the World" about Shackleton's exploration of Antarctica. Even less conventional is Maus, a graphic book (it's nonfiction in the sense that's it's essentially an oral history) of the Holocaust. All three books have blown me away with their writing and use of graphics.
The thing I worry about is why Language Arts teachers in high schools are responsible for teaching nonfiction writing and historical analysis under the new core standards that Utah and others are adopting. I'm not sure English teachers are well-equipped to help students understand these kinds of texts. I would hope that History teachers would start adopting texts like these or that English teachers would collaborate with History teachers in using these texts.
Sunday, January 15, 2012
Biking AROUND Mt. Timpanogos
Sunday, January 8, 2012
Eternity and Exaltation
We puzzled on this a while. Obviously, countries are not what is promised, but I suppose worlds might be, and those are pretty similar. But as we talked about it, I began to realize, thanks to the comments of others, that this scripture must tie in with D&C 121:41-46. In these verses, we are told that if we live righteously, we will influence others for good. Perhaps the promise of exaltation, then, is that we will live so well that others will want to be like us and will improve their own lives as a result.
This is an amazing blessing! I think of all the times that I make imperfect judgments, that I hurt (or at least fail to lift) others through misplaced words or ill-considered actions, or that I am too slothful or short-sighted to see the needs of others and how to aid them. If I can rid myself of these imperfections and instead influence others for good, without compulsion, just by example, then, yes, this is something that is motivating and worth lots of work.
The scriptures also talk about priesthood power being used to move mountains or rivers. I think mastery of elements must come along with the sort of righteousness necessary to achieve exaltation. Such mastery is also motivational to me, but for more prideful reasons. I just think it would be really cool to manipulate elements to see what is possible.
In the end, all of this ties into the idea that the glory of God is intelligence. Exaltation must therefore be about perfect intelligence: an ability to fully understand people and nature, their makeup and trajectory. As a social scientist keenly aware of our limitations in understanding and predicting human behavior, such a state of affairs does indeed seem heavenly. As a human being who marvels at nature and who takes deep satisfaction from the shape of ice in a stream and the color of a flower, it is doubly awesome. I can really place my hope in such a vision of heaven.
Sunday, January 1, 2012
Chilling over the Holidays
I really miss reading a newspaper or news magazine regularly. I need to make more time for that. I used to read the NY Times pretty regularly, but haven’t since I’ve been department chair. I still enjoy the Times when I catch glimpses of it, but would also like to branch out a bit to the Economist, the New Yorker, the Atlantic and perhaps others. I’m not much of a blog person. I try out blog sites from time to time, but usually find the analysis pretty superficial, and often referring to some more in-depth story published in one of these sources or something like them.
Sunday, December 18, 2011
Orderville Canyon
Sunday, December 11, 2011
Mt. Nebo Hike
Sunday, December 4, 2011
The Festival of Trees
We went to the Festival of the Trees yesterday. I think that’s the first time I’ve been since I was a kid. People donate and buy trees for Primary Children’s Hospital. Only it turns out that people also donate and buy a bunch of stuff surrounding the tree, which can amount to several thousand dollars worth of stuff, like sports memorabilia, digital pianos, ski passes, etc. It was quite a spectacle. I was rather taken in by it all despite the fact that it wasn’t really my cup of tea. Some of the trees and surrounding spreads were decorated in ways that seemed to say a lot about the person in whose memory they were created. There were some outdoorsy trees and superhero trees and sports trees to compete with the more traditional trees and female-oriented trees. I most enjoyed seeing photos of people in whose names the trees were dedicated. It presented the best and worst of Christmas: a charitable cause, giving, and memory of loved ones combined with spectacle, material goods, and glitz. It would be nice to have one without the other, but it seems there must needs be opposition in all things. Then in the middle of it all, I was arrested by one display. It had a rudimentary carpenter’s table with a simple sign: The Touch of the Master’s Hand. I had almost forgotten what Christmas was all about. It IS about giving and family, for sure. But it seems impossible for us as humans to have that without also having the materialism. The only way to overcome our all too human tendency to be attracted by this world is by combining our charitable impulses with Jesus. Charity without centering it in Christ can too easily get off track. It becomes generosity rather than charity. Generosity is certainly praiseworthy, and the Festival is laudable in so many ways. Yet it was much more meaningful once I remembered Jesus and the simplicity of His way.
Sunday, November 27, 2011
Ode To Thanksgiving
It’s Thanksgiving Weekend. My favorite holiday. I love Thanksgiving because it offers a lengthy break at just the right point in the semester. I love Thanksgiving because it has not yet been commercialized, and perhaps never will be, since it is simply enveloped by Christmas’ commercialization. It is the internet before all the ads: lovely, uncluttered, a place to connect in unhurried, simple fashion, without harassment. Thanksgiving is family, friends and food. It is playing games, hanging out, going on bike rides, reading a good book, or playing some football.
